Scott’s enthusiasm for the AERO Elite followed him home.
“I truly enjoyed running in these quite a bit, even the wife had to hear about it after my runs.”
Standing or walking in the shoe didn’t immediately suggest what was coming. The foam felt soft, and the geometry almost gave him the sensation of a negative heel-to-toe drop, but once he started putting more effort into his stride, the ride came alive. Scott described a forward-driving sensation that responded as he picked up the pace, with enough flexibility that the plate didn’t feel rigid underfoot. During workouts that mixed faster running with slower efforts and walking breaks, he felt the shoe changed gears comfortably.
Jenna also found plenty of spring, paired with cushioning that felt comfortable without being squishy. Unlike some plated shoes she’d tried, the AERO Elite made its plate noticeable to her. She still felt connected enough to the road to navigate her neighborhood’s uneven pavement, and the listed 4 mm drop didn’t draw much attention while running.
Her strongest endorsement came late in her 20-miler. She reported less leg fatigue, no foot ache afterward, and a pace about 35 seconds per mile faster than she typically runs over that distance. That’s one runner’s experience rather than a promise of faster times, but it explains why she was considering the shoe for her upcoming marathon.
Colleen found the spring, too. Fast intervals and a threshold effort of up to 20 minutes brought out the snappy, quick ride she enjoyed. For her, that sweet spot fell around 6:30–8:00 per mile. Warmups and cooldowns were another story. At easier efforts, the ride felt awkward and tippy, and downhill running felt wonky. She had hoped to take the AERO Elite on longer runs, but those experiences, along with Achilles soreness after wearing it, kept her testing focused on shorter workouts and racing.
MaryAnn also mentioned an Achilles issue that created some incompatibilities with the shoe. She wanted more cushioning and support than she felt the shoe delivered. She preferred running in it on the treadmill, and adding her own insoles helped somewhat, but neither adjustment made it a comfortable choice for longer running.
“There was definitely was not enough cushion or support for me. I do sometimes suffer from Achilles tendon issues and need a more supportive running shoe."
Takeaway: For runners who enjoy a springy, propulsive ride, Jenna’s and Scott’s experiences make the AERO Elite worth exploring for workouts and potentially longer efforts. Colleen’s feedback suggests a more specific role for runners who love it at speed but feel unsettled when slowing down. Before choosing it for a long race, spend time at the range of efforts you expect to run, including the slower miles. MaryAnn’s experience also makes clear that a generous stack of foam won’t necessarily deliver everyone’s preferred level of cushioning or support.