Garmin vs Apple Running Watches in 2025: Which One Should Runners Choose?

When it comes to choosing a GPS watch in 2025, Garmin vs Apple is one of the most common comparisons among runners. Whether you're training for your first 5K, building toward an ultramarathon, or simply trying to stay active during the week, the watch on your wrist can have a big impact on how you train, recover, and stay motivated.

Both Garmin and Apple make excellent running watches—but they do so with very different priorities. Garmin leads with endurance, data, and performance-driven features. Apple focuses on tech integration, health monitoring, and seamless smart features. So, how do you choose?

Let’s break down the top models, key differences, and what type of runner each brand serves best.

Garmin has long been the go-to brand for runners and outdoor athletes. Their devices are engineered for accuracy, durability, and deep performance tracking. From VO2 max to real-time stamina estimates, Garmin running watches are built to support serious training.

Apple, on the other hand, started in the lifestyle space but has made serious strides toward becoming a legitimate fitness platform. Especially with the Apple Watch Ultra 2, Apple now offers advanced GPS tracking and running form metrics—all within a sleek, high-tech smartwatch.

Garmin Forerunner 265 Praised for its runner-specific features like a bright AMOLED screen, accurate GPS tracking, and easy-to-read stats, making it a top choice for serious runners. 

Garmin Fenix 7X Pro Sapphire Solar A rugged, multi-sport watch with solar charging, advanced training metrics, and extensive mapping features, suitable for outdoor enthusiasts. 

Garmin Epix Pro (Gen 2) Combines a vibrant AMOLED display with comprehensive fitness tracking and smart features, catering to both athletes and tech-savvy users. 

Garmin Forerunner 55 An entry-level running watch offering accurate GPS tracking and essential health metrics, providing excellent value for beginners.

Related: Check Out This Data on 18 Popular Garmin Running Watches

🍏 Apple Watch Ultra 2

Apple’s most runner- and adventure-ready watch to date. Dual-frequency GPS, big battery upgrade, and more rugged build.

🍏 Apple Watch Series 10

A thinner, larger design with new health tools like sleep apnea detection. Best for runners who also want day-to-day lifestyle features.

🍏 Apple Watch SE (2nd Gen)

A budget-friendly model that covers the basics—heart rate, GPS, and activity tracking—without the higher price tag.

🛰️ GPS Accuracy and Performance

• Garmin: Uses multi-band GNSS in top models like the Fenix and Forerunner 965 for elite-level GPS accuracy—even in the woods or among skyscrapers.
• Apple: The Ultra 2 now includes dual-frequency GPS, putting it close to Garmin in most conditions. Excellent for roads and open trails; just a hair behind in rugged terrain.

🔋 Battery Life

• Garmin: Known for going the distance. The Fenix 7X Pro can last over 20 days with solar charging. Even basic models often get 7+ days per charge.
• Apple: The Ultra 2 offers up to 72 hours in low power mode, which is a big improvement—but daily or near-daily charging is still the norm.

💬 Smartwatch Features

• Garmin: Includes music storage, notifications, and Garmin Pay—but third-party apps are limited and navigation feels more utilitarian.
• Apple: Still the gold standard for smartwatch features. iMessages, phone calls, Siri, Apple Music, and full App Store access make it the best companion for everyday life.

📊 Training Features and Metrics

• Garmin: Deep training tools like training readiness, real-time stamina, recovery time, race predictor, and heat/altitude acclimation. Ideal for performance-focused runners.
• Apple: Features like heart rate zones, stride length, and custom interval workouts have improved—but still lean toward health + wellness over pure performance.

📱 Apps & Platforms

• Garmin Connect: A robust platform with customizable workouts, charts, and in-depth analysis. Syncs easily with third-party platforms like Strava and TrainingPeaks.
• Apple Health/Fitness+: Sleek and beginner-friendly. Works beautifully with other Apple devices, though you’ll likely want third-party apps (like Strava) for deeper analysis.

🛡️ Durability

• Garmin: Built to handle the elements. Rugged casings, sapphire glass, and physical buttons make Garmin watches perfect for trail running, rain, and cold weather.
• Apple: The Ultra 2 is Apple’s most durable model yet, with a titanium case and sapphire display. Other models like the SE and Series 10 are less rugged and better suited to casual wear.

💵 Budget & Value

• Garmin:
  • Forerunner 55: ~$200
  • Forerunner 265: ~$450
  • Fenix 7 Pro: ~$900+
  • ➤ Offers performance-focused features at every tier, making it a great value for dedicated runners.
• Apple:
  • Apple Watch SE: ~$250
  • Apple Watch Series 10: ~$399+
  • Apple Watch Ultra 2: ~$799
  • ➤ Higher upfront cost, but you’re also buying into the broader Apple ecosystem of apps, tech, and seamless syncing.

✅ Go with Garmin if:

• You want a running-first watch with real training tools.
• You need multi-day battery life for long runs or races.
• You value durability and performance over lifestyle perks.
• You enjoy diving into metrics and data analysis post-run.

✅ Choose Apple if:

• You want a smartwatch that also tracks runs.
• You already use an iPhone and love Apple’s ecosystem.
• You’re focused on wellness, casual running, or tech convenience.
• You prefer touchscreens, stylish design, and smart features on the go.

Garmin Forerunner 265: "My first Garmin and I have no regrets! I love the way it tracks my run, my steps, my training readiness & the daily suggested workouts. Garmin Connect is a great app as well. If you're thinking about switching to the Garmin, the 265s is a great start." -Brittany Simons

At the end of the day, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer in the Garmin vs Apple debate. Both offer high-quality running watches—just with different strengths. Your decision should reflect how you run, where you run, and how much you value things like data depth vs convenience.

🏁 Whether you’re Team Garmin or Team Apple, the most important thing is that your watch supports your goals, motivates you to move, and makes running a little more fun.

Which one are you wearing on your next run? Drop your thoughts in the comments!