Upload / Capture
The Hoka Cielo X1 2.0 arrives with big expectations: it’s supposed to be lighter, snappier, and speedier than its predecessor. When the first version came out, I was curious if it could pass as a legit race shoe. I liked it for uptempo runs, but it leaned more toward performance trainer than true racing flat. It was fine, but it wasn't something that I thought: wow I should race in this..especially since it was more expensive then most carbon plated shoes.
I’ve logged miles in Hokas for over ten years now, so naturally, I was interested to see how this update stacked up. At $275, it needs to deliver something serious. Is it finally on par with top-tier super shoes? I think so, but it's lost a lot of stability which many runners needed.
Quick Facts
Weight: 7.4 oz (210 g)
Stack Height: 46 mm heel / 39 mm forefoot
Price: $275
One of the more noticeable changes is the redesigned upper. It now features a lighter, thinner jacquard mesh that offers better ventilation and reduces weight. Even though the tongue isn’t gusseted, it’s held down well with a loop through the laces. The heel and collar are padded just enough to keep things comfortable, though the shoe now hugs the foot more tightly overall.
In short, the Hoka Cielo X1 2.0 almost disappears on your foot...which is what you want in a racing shoe.
The snugger fit was my only concern. It's not exactly “narrow,” but it's certainly narrower than before. I’m right on the edge of needing wide sizes, and this pair fits just barely. If my feet were any wider, it wouldn’t work. Other than that, the comfort and lockdown are both solid.
I typically wear between a women’s 10–11 wide, and the 11 fit best here. If a wide width had been available, I would’ve gone for it. For those with wider feet, going a full size up might be necessary. In all, the fit is just ok but it does run on the more narrow side.
The new midsole is where you feel the biggest shift. Hoka swapped in a softer PEBA foam that delivers a noticeable boost in energy return. It’s much more responsive than the older version...especially when running fast. The flip side? Less support.
The original Cielo had a surprising amount of stability for a carbon-plated shoe. This version gives that up. The midsole cutout is now on the medial side, which, combined with a narrower midfoot and heel, reduces the supportive feel. If the first model was your go-to for added control, this update may not be what you need. Not many carbon shoes offer stability, but the original Cielo was an exception. Now Hoka doesn't owe anyone stability, but many runners gravitated towards the Cielo because it did have some stability that other carbon plated shoes lacked.
With that said, the new rocker geometry kicks in earlier and creates a snappier transition. The updated foam and aggressive rocker give the shoe a noticeable pop at speed. It’s quick and definitely leans race day over daily trainer now.
Where does it land in my rotation? It’s strictly for workouts or race efforts. It performs best when you’re pushing the pace, and I think Hoka has made real strides in competing with other plated models. It finally feels like a racing shoe, not just a fast option for tempo days.
The outsole is grippy enough on dry pavement, but performance dips a little in wet conditions. If you plan to race in rain or on slick ground, it’s something to keep in mind.
Durability-wise, there’s enough rubber in key spots that I wouldn’t worry too much. Most carbon-plated options start breaking down around 50–100 miles, and I think this one will stretch closer to the upper end of that range.
After several test runs, I can confidently say this version is a clear improvement but not without trade-offs. It’s lighter, more responsive, and finally feels like a top-tier race day shoe. But it’s lost the stability that some runners appreciated. If you have a neutral stride and want a bouncier, more aggressive shoe for racing, this could be a great fit. If you need structure or support, you might want to look elsewhere. For me, it’s been a solid addition to my rotation and definitely an upgrade in terms of speed.
Who Should Buy the Hoka Cielo X1 2.0?
Who Should Not Buy the Hoka Cielo X1 2.0?
I was paid to write an honest shoe review of my choice.
Login to your account to leave a comment.
We Want to Give it to You!
